Athletic Hall of Fame Members
| 1979 | Stanley T. Schuyler | Founder of Muncy High School Athletic Hall of Fame |
| 1927 | Grant “Sonny” Taggert | Member 1st Football team |
| 1927 | Clay Lee | Football -Wrestling |
| 1929 | Leroy Anderson | Football |
| 1932 | George Wilt | Coaching |
| 1932 | Howard Ott | Coaching-Football-Baseball-Track |
| 1933 | Bob Wilt | Sports Journalism-Community Service |
| 1940 | Jim Egli | Football-Basketball-Wrestling |
| 1940 | Jack Whalen | Football-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1941 | Charlie Houseknecht | Football-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1941 | Charles Scott | Football |
| 1942 | Byron Dugan | Football-Wrestling |
| 1944 | Harold “Mick” Hill | Wrestling |
| 1945 | Howard “Pete” Pewterbaugh | Football-Wrestling-Baseball |
| 1946 | Harold “Cork” Egli | Football-Wrestling-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1949 | Stan Lucas | Football-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1951 | Wesley “Bud” Mann | Baseball-Basketball |
| 1951 | John “Tootie” Rohm | Football-Baseball-Wrestling |
| 1952 | Jim Brittain | Football-Wrestling-Officiating |
| 1952 | Dave Wallis | Football-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1952 | Marlin Wolfe | Football-Baseball |
| 1952 | Gerald Yoder | Wrestling-Baseball |
| 1953 | Ralph “Butch” Feigles | Baseball-Football-Wrestling |
| 1954 | Richard Brittain | Football-Wrestling |
| 1954 | Earl Poust | Wrestling-Coaching |
| 1955 | Max Stackhouse | Football-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1955 | Don Baylor | Football-Wrestling-Baseball |
| 1955 | Ken Hill | Basketball-Baseball-Football |
| 1956 | Robert Rohm | Football-Wrestling-Baseball-Coaching |
| 1957 | Larry Lauchle | Wrestling-Coaching-Olympics |
| 1957 | Don “Jake” Poust | Football-Wrestling-Coaching-Officiating |
| 1958 | Gary Allen | Football-Wrestling |
| 1959 | Allen Smith | Wrestling |
| 1959 | Bill Hughes | Wrestling-Football-Coaching-Officiating |
| 1962 | Denny Warg | Football-Basketball |
| 1963 | Thomas Ott | Football-Wrestling-Officiating |
| 1963 | Bill Scott | Football-Wrestling |
| 1964 | Ed Heincelman | Wrestling |
| 1964 | Dave Michael | Basketball |
| 1965 | Ron Speary | Gymnastics-Football |
| 1965 | Carmen Mack | Basketball, Football, Baseball |
| 1966 | John Brink | Coaching-Baseball-Basketball |
| 1967 | Dana Balum | Football-Wrestling-Coaching |
| 1967 | Larry Sones | Football-Wrestling-Coaching |
| 1968 | Roger Campbell | Football-Wrestling |
| 1968 | Jan Pfleegor | Swimming |
| 1970 | Ed Ott | Football-Baseball-Wrestling-Pro Baseball |
| 1972 | Galen Miller | Football-Basketball-Baseball-Officiating-Track |
| 1973 | Lon Balum | Wrestling |
| 1976 | Ron Mack | Football-Tennis |
| 1976 | Mark Miller | Basketball |
| 1979 | Woody Fry | Wrestling |
| 1979 | By Singer | Football-Basketball-Wrestling-Baseball |
| 1980 | Wendy Kutz | Basketball-Tennis |
| 1981 | Marcie Wallis | Swimming-Coaching |
| 1985 | Karen Kurtz | Tennis – Basketball |
| 1987 | Tommy Rishel | Football-Wrestling-Softball-Baseball |
| 1990 | Cam Scholvin | Football- Basketball-Baseball |
| 1990 | Jason Scott | Basketball |
| 1992 | Dave Steele | Basketball-Football |
| 1993 | Mike Gaydon | Basketball-Soccer |
| 1993 | Dr. Christina Steinbacher-Reed | Basketball – Field Hockey |
| 1994 | Jamie DeJesus | Basketball-Tennis |
| 1995 | Miss Force | Softball-Coaching |
| 1998 | Jamie Campbell | Football-Basketball-Wrestling-Baseball |
| 1998 | Ryan Koch | Football-Basketball-Baseball |
| 1999 | Pete Gaydon | Football-Wrestling |
| 1999 | Patti Hatches | Basketball-Tennis |
| 2000 | Kathy Brehm | Softball-basketball |
| 2001 | Justin Grenoble | Football, Baseball, Basketball |
| 2002 | Amy Kile-McPhail | Basketball-softball-soccer-coaching |
| 2004 | Nate Messner | Baseball-Football,Basketball |
| 2004 | Trevor Egli | Basketball-Football-Baseball-Coaching |
| 2004 | Adam Leonard | Basketball-Football-Coaching |
| 2005 | Tyler Mensch | Soccer-Baseball-Basketball-Football-Coaching |
| 2007 | Zach Sarginger | Football, Basketball, Baseball |
| 2008 | Jordan Rishel Sarginger | Field Hockey, Basketball, Softball |
| 2011 | Ryan Hembury | Football, Wrestling |
| 2011 | Zach Strickland | Wrestling |
| 2013 | Troy Hembury | Wrestling, Football, Baseball |